The Care and Feeding of the Solitary Diner: A Restaurant Primer

I can’t possibly be the first blogger/writer to address this subject so excuse me if this is beating a dead horse, but I have developed quite an appreciation for the trials and tribulations of restaurant dining for the single person (anyone, who for any reason, has chosen to dine alone) over the last year.

And I know from conversations with friends and relatives that this is a dilema faced by many, many people, so it frankly boggles my mind that the service industry at large hasn’t adopted an approach to this. It leaves me with the distinct impression that the business of a solo diner is simply not desired at many establishments. A notion that defies reason when you consider that I don’t always eat alone–and in fact often eat with large groups of people. A bad solo experience is not likely to incline me towards suggesting a location for friends.

Also, I will offer this disclaimer, which will hopefully calm the reactions of some hardened service personnel–this entry assumes that the solitary diner in question is not a complete jackass. If you are a rude, demanding, sloppy, sexist or otherwise lecherous individual, and if you tip like an asshat, you get what you deserve.

That being said, my experience as a lone diner in restaurants ranging from very nice to just above fast food, typically falls into one of three themes:

1. She is eating alone so let’s make sure she eats and gets out as quickly as possible.

This is infuriating from the standpoint that I tend to be going out to eat because not only would I like a nice meal but I’d also like to be out and about and surrounded by people for a little while before I return to my quiet home. I typically bring a book or magazine, which I always politely close when the wait staff approaches and I’m always more than happy to sit at the bar or at a “less desirable” table (in which case, if you seat me at a four top during dinner rush you really weren’t thinking). Also, I habitually try to do dinner and lunch early to avoid dealing with feeling rushed because of lines.

Two nights ago I had dinner at a very nice Italian place. I ordered an imported beer, a fairly expensive pasta dish and fully intended to enjoy dessert as well. My bread had barely reached the table before my meal was served. That was followed almost immediately by a bill–no offer of an additional beer or a glance at the dessert menu. Message heard and understood. I won’t be coming here again anytime soon.

2. She is dining alone, poor thing, she must be so lonely, let’s smother her.

Do I even need to explain why that’s annoying? Thank you for being attentive but we are not BFF. I need some tea, not every two minutes and not accompanied by the story of your life. Still and all, it is better than its evil sister:

3. She is dining alone and is therefore invisible.

I firmly believe that it is possible to strike a balance between these two approaches. If I am sitting at a table in a restaurant I expect to be waited on, at least to the extent that I’d like a drink and some food within a reasonable amount of time. And really, breadbaskets for one can still actually have some bread in them.

I don’t need you to hover, but I’d also prefer that you not ignore me entirely either. Beverages run out. Sauces are occasionally needed. If you are convinced upon site of me that as a solo diner I am not going to leave you a very good tip then you are fulfilling that prophecy by leaving me an empty beer or tea glass for 30 minutes. And I’d have to say that if business where you work is so strained that your tips are likely to be severely impacted by waiting on me for 45 minutes then you probably ought to go find a better place to work.

I think I’m a good patron. I tip 20 percent. I never leave less than three dollars on a table regardless of the total ($8 total = $3 tip). I don’t make a mess. I don’t snap my fingers and yell, “Miss!” across a room unless I’ve seriously been pushed to my limit by tediously absent service. I tend to order high-end entrees (not the dollar menu) and almost always add to that total with alcohol. And I’m a creature of habit who would very much like to find one or two reasonbly decent places to have dinner ALONE during the week. I am brand loyal and would encourage friends and family to reward such establishments with their own business.

So why is it still so rare in this day and age, to be able to dine alone without fear of reprisal?

I keep doing it. I’ll be damned if I’m going to order take-out all the time and cower in my apartment with a six-pack because it’s less annoying than dealing with the crap-shoot of solo dining.

Tonight I discovered Wolfgang Puck Express. Relatively good food, reasonbly priced. Beer is served and best yet, you order at a counter and pick it up yourself–wait staff is limited to clean-up–and the seating area was lovely and relaxing, making me want to linger a while and read my book.

Nevertheless, I maintain that service for the solitary diner is not an unreasonable or impossible expectation and I am actively seeking satisfaction on this front. And when I find it, you can count on me telling everyone I know. You can take that tip to the bank.

11 Comment(s)

  1. “here here!”

    I rarely get number two but frequently experience 1 and 3. And yeah, why do they assume that one person eating alone will tip poorly. As a womyn who has lived on tips, I also always tip well, usually a bit too well, but you’re right if you treat me as though you’ve made up my mind…this will become a self-fulfilling prophecy and your tip will suffer.

    I think this is especially bad for me as i ALWAYS drink water, not because i’m cheap but because i like water best. I sat the other day with an empty water glass in front of me for 18 minutes…that is unreasonable. She didn’t even stop by my table between delivering the food and bringing the check.

    I’m with you on this single dining thing.

    towanda | Feb 5, 2006 | Reply

  2. I go over to the pizza/burger place near my office quite a bit, not only because their burgers rock, but because they actually treat me like a person. They now have my order memorized, and let me read in peace, only checking in once or twice to make sure it’s all OK.

    All I can say is, when you find a good place, go back. I’ve been pretty lucky in general, but I have certainly experienced all three varieties. #2 pisses me off especially; look, I’m not a poor lost puppy, I just want some pasta I don’t have to cook for myself, okay? Sheesh.

    Christina | Feb 5, 2006 | Reply

  3. AMEN from a woman who travels alone a lot and therefore ends up eating alone in whatever restaurant is closest to the hotel (and I generally end up with #3). I actually had excellent service in the Holiday Inn in Frankfort, KY, which shocked the hell out of me because very little else about that hotel was any good. Of course, I think the server just liked me because I _wasn’t_ trying to get out of the nice restaurant in under 20 minutes, unlike the party of ten that came in before me. So she was thrilled that I was patient and polite and obviously enjoyed my (excellent) steak.

    Anyhow, totally with you there.

    Elizabeth F. | Feb 6, 2006 | Reply

  4. I have several friends who LOVE TGIAppleO’CharleyBenabies. I despise them because I eat out so much. Bad service at a Bennigans in Akron has crossed them off my list permenantly. Most chains I’m over eating at.

    Bout the only one that I really enjoy is Cracker Barrel. Friendly, good food, well lit without blinding, and I can haul my paper/book there without any problem.

    Roger B | Feb 7, 2006 | Reply

  5. I was smothered last night - my waiter sat down at the table with me to take my order. He also was obviously unhappy that I ordered a second glass of wine, despite offering the single guy diner sitting across from me another beer.

    Jodi | Feb 7, 2006 | Reply

  6. I find that Bob Evans is usually not bad by myself also. I’m not sure if there is a Cracker Barrel near me.

    And while I’m sure they’re just trying to be friendly, dining alone is really not an invitation for the waiter to sit down with you. Sheesh.

    AmyMo | Feb 7, 2006 | Reply

  7. I ate with Amy at a little breakfast place I frequent in Chicago. She’s a tyrant. Take this article with a grain of salt.

    Joe | Feb 7, 2006 | Reply

  8. Christopher was the one our waitress was apparently out to get!

    AmyMo | Feb 7, 2006 | Reply

  9. Though there are many stories I could tell from my one experience with Amy at breakfast, I’ll only dwell on one:

    When the waitress placed Amy’s eggs on the table, Amy took one look, scrunched her nose, and immediately (instinctively?) punched the waitress in the stomach. Once keeled over, Amy then grabbed the waitress back the back of her hair and said (in this creepy dead-calm voice): “I said ‘Over Easy.’ These eggs are clearly Over Medium. Tell me, my dear, how am I supposed to dip my toast if my eggs aren’t Over Easy? ”

    Suddenly, all emotion left Amy’s eyes. Obviously, she had snapped. Amythen proceeded to rub the waitress’ nose in her eggs, all the while cackling: “HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO DIP MY TOAST?! HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO DIP MY TOAST?!”

    It was chilling, to say the least.

    Joe | Feb 7, 2006 | Reply

  10. Which is made all the more amusing by the fact I had French Toast and Bacon that morning.

    AmyMo | Feb 7, 2006 | Reply

  11. Whatever you say, Norman Bates.

    Joe | Feb 7, 2006 | Reply

Post a Comment